Mouse rant blog vent mouse.

Monday, January 17, 2005

The brainiac wars

Boy, am I familiar with these. An ex-boyfriend once told me that I need to have a meek, submissive boyfriend after we quarrelled, and I was really offended and told him so. And with very feminist language--I explained that if he had this model of relationships where one person always dominates, he would probably always be lonesome. Anyway, I was put in mind of that after reading Lauren's blog post about dealing with a guy at a party who seems to have been using the old flirting method of putting a girl in her place by trying to intimidate her intellectually. (He defends himself in the comments section, but I am only more convinced of her side of the story because of what he says. Read it and see.)

For the record, my current boyfriend is not meek or submissive but also isn't overly committed to making me fall in line with his opinion. Trying to bully others into line is something that people do associate with leftists, but it's a behavior that knows no political or intellectual bounds that I can think of. The only strong correlation between this and any other trait, in my experience, is a sort of insecure snobbishness. Some insecure snobs are like me--we talk a big game but capitulate at the first sign of disagreement and hide in the corner. And some are just bullies.

What I don't get and will never get is why some bullying types think that their behavior is so damn sexy. What's clear is that the guys who have pulled this shit on me that was pulled on Lauren tend to single out topics that they have correctly guessed are things I care about. My all-time favorite story on this subject is the guy who hit on me by offering to buy me a beer that's better than the one I had in my hand. Since I was drinking Miller Lite, there is no reason to know that I have a secret side that loves expensive beer, but there you go.

There's no doubt when you run across someone who hits on you by making statements that convey that he thinks that you are the sort of woman who appreciates what he does, though obviously you are not in his league, about what his motivations are. I mean, it's tempting to believe that you could date someone who both sppreciates what you are talking about, but knows less than you and so sits in rapt attention while you pontificate. Hell, I'm enthralled myself. But c'mon. Does it ever work?

I have been hit on this way by more guys I can count. Either they thought they knew more about literature, art, beer, music, whatever, and it was very important that I knew that right away. And it's never really worked. (Well, not since I was legal.) I always fell for guys that I can blah blah with back and forth, who I do respect but I find also respect me. You know, like a friend. One of the things I really enjoy about my boyfriend and about my closest friends, male or female, is that we can be relaxed and excited about stuff we like without getting our egos all in a tangle over it. Just listening to that show Pop Vultures the other day, my boyfriend turned to me and said, "Damn, I think that we could do a show like this. Like with me and you, and ____ and ___. Hmmm.... Who else?" And I offered a couple other names, saying why I thought those people would have unique and valuable perspectives.

I guess that's why I just don't get all the fucking infighting that occurs in any leftist arena, be it men wanting women to take on roles as a chorus of admirers or the punks who beat up Jello Biafra because they thought he had "sold out". I'm as egotistical as the next person, but even I think there's a lot of value in respecting other people, especially those people you know for a fact have similiar goals and values. C'mon now--there's bigger enemies to fight.

And I really don't get any guy whose head is so far up his ass that he can't see that bulldozing women is offensive and sexist and isn't going to get you into the beds of the women whose brains are so attractive in the first place.

27 Comments:

Blogger FoolishOwl said...

Is that URL for the article right? I'm unable to reach the site. Given that the URL suggests it's about sexism in the radical left, I feel obligated to read it carefully before saying too much.

I have seen intellectual bullying and sexist behavior on the part of leftists who should have known better. On the other hand, I think it's *extremely* important that people argue hard and clearly for a political position, and many times I've seen "let's all be nice and respectful" used as an excuse to silence valid arguments.

1/17/2005

 
Blogger Amanda Marcotte said...

It works for me, but trying Feministe's link if it doesn't work.

The push to be "agreeable" is problematic, I agree (smirk), but I think that the major problem is not being agreeable but being so pig-headed that you are so sure of your own righteousness that you can't see that you are bulldozing others. I'm guilty of it, true, but I think I avoid the worst of it. I do make an effort to take other people seriously unless they really do strike me as tedious idealogues.

But there are some leftists that are so full of themselves that they don't see what they are doing, and that alone is going to cause infighting and it's very tiring. I mean, I was reading something today that briefly referenced Jello Biafra getting the shit beat out of him, which is why I brought it up, and suffice it to say, you have to be really out of your mind to do something like that. I live in Texas and so I have no experience with men who echo pseudo-feminist sentiments to hit on girls, so I've been spared that. I have no idea how to feel about that, but I'm leaning towards being grateful that our sexists are pretty in your face about it.

1/17/2005

 
Blogger FoolishOwl said...

I tried the link on the sidebar, and that didn't work, either. It may be my "bargain" ISP at work again.

Anyway, your past arguments don't strike me as coming from the "let's all be nice" contingent. Some of my less pleasant experiences when I started out as a socialist activist were with coalition meetings and the like in which, when arguments broke out, people would clamp down upon them with faux-feminist arguments like, "I think there's too much masculine energy in the room." It's faux-feminist because it implies that women don't, and shouldn't, argue strongly for a point of view.

Of course, argument and debate is supposed to be an interaction, but lots of people are in love with the sound of their own voice. It seems like the socialist group I'm part of spends almost as much time teaching people when to shut up and listen as it does teaching people to stand up and speak. And failing to shut up seems to be much, much more common among men.

I've also seen a number of occasions when we've had to kick men out of the group for sexist behavior. I can't remember ever having to kick someone out for racist behavior.

It's not so much men being pseudo-feminist as a gambit to hit on women, from what I've seen, as men who think that declaring themselves radical leftists absolves them of all responsibility for their behavior, and who think that associating themselves with the left gives them some sort of right to hit on any women associated with the left.

1/17/2005

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I hate that stereotype that feminist-women only want submissive, docile, and meek male-partners, just as much as I hate the 'men want weak and submissive girlfriends' stereotype. No one should dominate a relationship. Both partners will realize a happier and loving relationship if they work together equally to sustain the relationship.

As for male intimidation via intellectual bullying; yeah, sometimes I hear, "women are too emotionally hysterical and irrational to have an intelligent opinion about anything," bullshit. Like I said...BULLSHIT!! I have encountered men who try to bully women into denouncing their own opinions and take on the opinions of their men. Thankfully, these men have been few in my life and I'm pretty sure that these kinds of bullying men are few in general....at least I hope so.

I won't renounce my opinions and views for anyone, but at the same time, I don't, nor will I ever ask my future male-partner to renounce his opinions and views.
People within a relationship need to realize that sometimes you won't always agree on everything, and you have to accept and respect that. Peacefully agree to disagree, and forget about your damn ego. Or else, ruin your relationship due to infighting and butting heads.

1/17/2005

 
Blogger FoolishOwl said...

Okay, I got the link to work. I agree -- that guy was a pig.

1/17/2005

 
Blogger Amanda Marcotte said...

Yeah, I have no desire to be nice, which gets me in trouble, because people in a sexist society tend to rate me as abrasive or angry when the same words coming from a man would be taken in good humor. But we're all the same page, so let me yell an "Amen!" here. I tend to run in DIY circles where there is a lot of innovation but no internal control, so gross sexists like this guy get in. The good news is that a committment to not censoring means that women have an opportunity to speak back, and more often than not, they win the last word out of sheer reality.

1/17/2005

 
Blogger Amanda Marcotte said...

Completely understood. I too run over people totally on accident. But I definitely think this is one of those situations, in part because I doubt Lauren would lie, but mostly because I read his rebuttals and they were pretty typical--while trying to shed the sexist label, he spewed sexism, even at one point saying that he pretended to care for her sake.

I can tell the difference between harmless blowhard stuff and sexism. Usually, it's easy to tell by watching the blowhard (like myself) choose who gets to interrupt. I let women, men, dogs and cats interrupt me. Some men are particular--only men get to interrupt.

1/17/2005

 
Blogger mythago said...

What I don't get and will never get is why some bullying types think that their behavior is so damn sexy.They don't think their behavior is sexy. They don't care what *you* think of them--your opinion is not relevant. What's going on is that you've stood up to their bulldozing, therefore you are an exciting *challenge.* Guys like that get all hot at the idea of a woman who they have to work to put in her place.

1/17/2005

 
Blogger FoolishOwl said...

I understand what Heydt means. I don't think of myself as aggressive or domineering, but I do talk over people -- particularly women. I've had to catch myself doing that now and again, and a few times, others have cut me off and told me what I was doing.

Just because I know I'm in a sexist society, and mean to oppose sexism, doesn't mean I'm magically cured of the taint. It takes some effort.

What most disgusted me about the scenario at the party described was that no one apologized, or seemed to consider that, if a newcomer thought they were being sexist, that they might be doing something wrong. It's possible that an accusation of sexism might be unfair, but there's no hint that "Shane," or any of the others, even considered the possibility that they'd erred. It suggests that they really don't care enough to take fighting oppression *seriously*.

1/18/2005

 
Blogger Dada said...

Does it ever work? Mixed results, at best. Unfortunately, I know this because as a young graduate student I sadly resembled the obnoxious, overbearing boys you've described. I liked to think of myself as a passionate, committed intellectual, and foolishly believed that this excused my proclivity for dominating discussions and turning casual conversations into heated arguments. I'd like to think I've outgrown these tendencies, but the truth is that it's hard to shake such ingrained patterns of behavior. That's the first point I want to make: male aggression (whether physical or intellectual) is rewarded and reinforced in our culture. I was praised by professors, male and female alike, received fellowships and accolades, and quickly rose above my peers in the estimation of the faculty. And yes, on more than one occasion, this academic machismo got me laid. Talk about positive reinforcement!
That's the second point: all of this blustering concealed a huge amount of self-doubt. I craved approval, and when I realized that this sort of behavior racked it up by the truckload, I thought for sure I'd found my calling. But at the heart of my intellectual bravado was a deep-seated insecurity. Now, when I encounter men who mirror my former self, I want to put my arm around their shoulders and tell them, "It's OK. I know you're scared, but letting your guard down and walking with humility is really the only way you'll make the human connections that cause the fear to subside." I don't, but I want to.
I guess all I'm really saying is that there may be more at work here than stereotypical masculine desires for domination over women, or preening, overconfident male egos. I think it's far more likely that you're witnessing the embarrassing behavior of someone who just doesn't know how to live outside of the gender identities our culture ascribes. Then again, maybe he's just an asshole.

1/18/2005

 
Blogger Dada said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

1/18/2005

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

He defends himself in the comments section, but I am only more convinced of her side of the story because of what he says. Read it and see.)I don't even think you need to read what he says: everything she says is confirmed by the fact that he posts four seperate and sequential comments all arguing that he isn't a bulldozer! He's not a bully! He WASN'T BEING INTIMINDATING, OKAY??I'd be much more conviced of the dude's willingness to listen respectfully to others if he had, you know, listened respectfully. Or even shut up long enough to let someone, anyone, speak.

Happily, though, this type is the flesh-and-blood version of a troll; if ignored for long enough they eventually go away, and they're rarely found anyplace where they might be expected to do any actual work. It also helps to know that they go away all by themselves once you get old and wrinkly, since they only find it exciting to intellectually dominate fresh-faced young things. This is one of the blessings of age.

1/20/2005

 
Blogger WebsiteHosting1.com said...

**eLearning**

10/29/2005

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

to all of the major RSS feed directories on the Internet.

11/01/2005

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

What If This Could All Happen Automatically,
with a simple push of a button.....

11/07/2005

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Call toll FREE 1-866-602-6411 for more info.

11/11/2005

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I enjoyed your free sexy pic blog. You might find this lingerie site interesting : SexyBedroomAttire.com

11/16/2005

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

hey did you know you can get a free ipod pretty easily?
just go to www.getipodsforfree.com, sign up and do an offer

11/17/2005

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

casino targeted traffic A fantasic way to get people to your website fast. Not only will you get a massive amount of real visitors to your websiite, we can target visitors so you only receive people who are interested in what your selling or what your writing about. Imagion for a second you have a blog subject related to Rugby we can send you people who would join your blog and talk about that same subject. Targeted Traffic can also increase your sales to your website as we can send you real people who are active and looking for your products. So if you are selling anything or you have services, come have a read at how we can Increase sales We have lots more information on our website so come check us out. casino targeted traffic. Get your own Article Directory for your Blog or website (reprint rights available)
Also Stay tuned to this Site (you may want to keep this link) 2011 NZ WORLD CUP And dont forget to check out the World Cup 2011 Blog

12/16/2005

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Buying Targeted Traffic Get Targeted Traffic to your website. A fantasic way to get people to your website fast. Not only will you get a massive amount of real visitors to your websiite, we can target visitors so you only receive people who are interested in what your selling or what your website is about. Imagion for a second you have a blog subject related to the New Zealand Rugby World Cup 2011 We can send you people who would join your blog and talk about that same subject. en increase language site traffic web can also increase your sales to your website as we can send you real people who are active and looking for your products. So if you are selling anything or you have services, come have a read at how we can Increase sales We have lots more information on our website so come check us out. en increase language site traffic web

12/22/2005

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The ultimate internet marketing website is www.TheOnlinePromoters.com

12/27/2005

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

nice blog, I really like what you have done here and look forward to future updates. I have a website you might like

weight loss clinic

1/15/2006

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello! While I was searching for info on online dating louisville I somehow landed here. I am certainly glad I stopped by for a read. While I am here, I just wanted to drop a quick note to comment your blog...now to move on and continue my search for online dating louisville. Thanks for the post.

1/17/2006

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

From what I can see, not many blogs talk about stuff like krispy kreme and the low carb diet and that is sad. I think your blog is great that way.

keep it up.

1/19/2006

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It is great fun to read all these good blogs. Your's is very nice. I have been looking for information about glucose levels + low carbohydrates and have not really found it anywhere but here: http://atkinsdiet.find-it-first.biz

Has anyone else seen it elsewhere?

1/19/2006

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Keep up the good work! I�ve been looking for photo personals online and I found this site - http://top-personals.net. It�s amazing that you can find utah gay personals and so many picture personal ads from your area there.

1/21/2006

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Some blogs are just too powerful.
Thanks.
Found this site while searching for
for turbo traffic.
http://www.1st-choice-4-website-traffic.com
turbo traffic

3/17/2006

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home